Noodler's Ink vs. Diamine: Which Offers Better Value?

Quick Answer

If you need permanent, archival inks for documents or art, Noodler's offers specialized options like #41 Brown with bulletproof properties. If you prefer a vast color palette and consistent flow at a low price, Diamine is a strong contender. Both are budget-friendly, but your choice hinges on permanence versus color variety.

Fountain pen enthusiasts often debate between Noodler's Ink and Diamine. Both brands offer affordable, high-quality inks, but they cater to different priorities. This comparison focuses on value, examining price, permanence, color range, and practical considerations to help you decide.

We'll use specific Noodler's products to illustrate key points, while discussing Diamine's general characteristics based on its reputation. Remember that individual ink properties can vary, so always test before committing.

Price and Bottle Size

Noodler's typically sells 3 oz bottles for around $6.25, as seen with 19029 Turquoise of the Mesas and 19063 #41 Brown. This offers a low cost per milliliter, making it economical for heavy users. Diamine's standard 30 ml bottles are similarly affordable, but you get less ink per purchase.

However, Diamine offers smaller bottles, which are great for trying multiple colors without committing to a large volume. Noodler's larger bottles are better if you have a favorite shade you use daily. The trade-off is between upfront cost and long-term value.

• Consider your writing volume: frequent writers benefit from Noodler's larger bottles.
• If you like variety, Diamine's smaller bottles let you collect more colors for the same budget.

Permanence and Archival Properties

Noodler's is famous for its bulletproof and waterproof inks. For example, 19063 #41 Brown is described as forge resistant, water resistant, and bulletproof, offering archival quality. This is a major advantage for legal documents, checks, or any writing that must withstand the test of time.

Diamine offers some permanent inks, but most of its line is not marketed as archival. If permanence is a priority, Noodler's has a clear edge. If you're journaling and don't need waterproofness, Diamine's standard inks are perfectly fine and often have more vibrant colors.

• For important documents, choose Noodler's bulletproof inks like #41 Brown.
• For everyday notes, permanence may not matter, so Diamine's color range becomes more attractive.

Color Range and Vibrancy

Diamine is renowned for its extensive color catalog, with hundreds of shades, including many sheening and shimmering options. This makes it a favorite for artists and hobbyists who love experimenting. Noodler's also has a wide range, but it's not as extensive as Diamine's.

Noodler's colors often have a unique character, like the vibrant turquoise of 19029 Turquoise of the Mesas, inspired by the American Southwest. However, Diamine's consistency and availability of specialty inks (like sheening) might appeal more to those seeking specific effects.

• If you want a specific shade or effect, Diamine's larger catalog increases your chances.
• If you prefer unique, story-driven colors, Noodler's has distinctive options like Turquoise of the Mesas.

Value Trade-offs

• Cost per milliliter: Noodler's 3 oz bottles offer more ink for the price compared to Diamine's 30 ml bottles. If you write a lot, Noodler's gives more bang for your buck.
• Permanence: Noodler's offers bulletproof options like #41 Brown, while Diamine's standard inks are not archival. Choose Noodler's for important documents that need to last.
• Color selection: Diamine has a larger, more diverse color range, including specialty sheens and shimmers. If you love variety, Diamine might be more satisfying.

Noodler's Ink Examples

• 19063 #41 Brown: Forge resistant, water resistant, and bulletproof, offering archival quality. This makes it ideal for legal documents or any writing that needs to last without fading or smudging.
• 19029 Turquoise of the Mesas: A vibrant turquoise hue inspired by the American Southwest. Shows Noodler's ability to create unique, evocative colors that stand out in your writing.

Which Should You Choose?

Best for

• Writers who need permanent, archival ink for legal, exam, or art purposes
• Budget-conscious users who want the lowest cost per milliliter

Not for

• Ink collectors seeking a huge variety of colors and effects
• Those who prefer smaller bottles to try many shades without commitment

Both Noodler's and Diamine offer excellent value, but for different reasons. Noodler's wins on permanence and bulk economy, while Diamine excels in color diversity and flexibility. Assess your priorities—archival needs versus color exploration—and you'll find the perfect match for your fountain pen.