Baystate Blue vs. Other Permanent Blues: A Detailed Comparison

When it comes to permanent blue inks, Noodler's Baystate Blue is often the first name that comes to mind. Its legendary intensity and bulletproof permanence have made it a favorite among fountain pen enthusiasts. But is it the right choice for everyone? In this comparison, we'll pit Baystate Blue against other permanent blue inks in the Noodler's lineup, examining factors like permanence, behavior, and overall writing experience.

Whether you're a student needing archival quality, an artist looking for a vibrant hue, or a professional seeking a reliable everyday ink, understanding the differences between these blues is crucial. We'll explore the unique properties of each, including the flex options and the famous bulletproof line, to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Permanent Blues: What Does 'Bulletproof' Mean?

Noodler's uses the term 'bulletproof' to describe inks that are resistant to water, light, and even chemical attacks. These inks are designed to be archival, meaning they won't fade or wash away over time. Baystate Blue is one of the most notorious bulletproof inks, known for its stunning, electric blue color that seems to glow on the page. However, its permanence comes with a trade-off: it can stain pens and surfaces if not handled carefully.

Other permanent blues in the Noodler's lineup offer different balances of permanence and behavior. For instance, the 'Eel' series includes lubricated inks that are also bulletproof, while some flex inks are designed for calligraphy and may not be as permanent. Understanding these distinctions is key to choosing the right ink for your needs.

• Bulletproof inks are resistant to water, light, and chemicals.
• Baystate Blue is known for its extreme permanence and vibrant color.
• Consider the trade-off between permanence and pen maintenance.

Baystate Blue vs. Bulletproof Blues: The Classic Choice

Baystate Blue is often compared to other bulletproof blues like the 19094 Akhmatova, which is a deep, saturated blue with a more subdued tone. While Baystate Blue is electric and eye-catching, Akhmatova offers a more professional, understated look. Both are bulletproof, but they behave differently on paper. Baystate Blue has a tendency to feather on low-quality paper, while Akhmatova is better behaved in that regard.

Another popular bulletproof option is the 19052 Dark Matter, which is a darker, almost navy blue. Dark Matter is known for its excellent flow and quick drying time, making it a great choice for left-handed writers. Baystate Blue, on the other hand, has a longer dry time and can smear if not allowed to set. If you prioritize permanence above all, Baystate Blue is hard to beat, but if you need a more practical everyday ink, these alternatives may suit you better.

• Baystate Blue is brighter and more vibrant than Akhmatova.
• Dark Matter offers faster drying and better flow.
• Consider paper quality when using Baystate Blue.

Flex Nibs and Permanent Blues: The Best of Both Worlds

For those who enjoy line variation, flex nib pens are a joy. Noodler's offers several permanent blue inks that pair beautifully with flex nibs. The 15025 Arizona Flex is a stunning turquoise-blue that works wonderfully with flex pens, providing beautiful shading and line variation. While it may not be as permanent as Baystate Blue, it still offers good water resistance and is a favorite among calligraphers.

Another flex-friendly option is the 14040 Northern Pike Konrad Flex, which is a deep blue with a hint of teal. This ink is specifically designed for use with the Konrad flex pen, and it flows beautifully, allowing for expressive writing. If you're looking for a permanent blue that also enhances your flex writing experience, these are excellent choices. Baystate Blue, while permanent, can be too saturated for flex nibs, often clogging or pooling in the tines.

• Arizona Flex offers beautiful shading and line variation.
• Northern Pike Konrad Flex is designed for flex pens.
• Baystate Blue may be too thick for flex nibs.

Comparing Performance: Flow, Drying Time, and Maintenance

When comparing permanent blues, it's essential to consider how they perform in daily use. Baystate Blue is notorious for its high maintenance: it can stain pens, and if left in a pen for too long, it can be difficult to clean. It also has a longer drying time, which can be a downside for left-handed writers or those who need to write quickly. On the other hand, the 19204 Eel Gruene Cactus is a bulletproof green-blue that includes a lubricating agent, making it smoother and easier to clean. It dries faster and is less prone to smudging.

If you're willing to trade a bit of permanence for convenience, the 19174 Atlantic Salmon HL is a permanent blue with a lovely salmon undertone, but it's not as bulletproof as Baystate Blue. It flows well and is easier to maintain. Ultimately, the choice comes down to your priorities: if you need the ultimate in permanence and don't mind the extra care, Baystate Blue is the way to go. But if you want a permanent blue that's more user-friendly, consider one of the alternatives.

• Baystate Blue requires careful pen maintenance.
• Eel Gruene Cactus is lubricated and easier to clean.
• Atlantic Salmon HL offers a balance of permanence and ease.

Making the Choice: Which Permanent Blue Is Right for You?

Choosing between Baystate Blue and other permanent blues ultimately depends on your specific needs. If you're an artist or someone who requires the most intense, permanent blue possible, Baystate Blue is unmatched. Its vibrancy and permanence are legendary, and with proper care, it can be a rewarding ink to use. However, if you're a student or professional who needs a reliable everyday ink that won't stain your pens or smear, you might prefer a more forgiving option like the 19094 Akhmatova or the 19052 Dark Matter.

For those who love flex writing, the 15025 Arizona Flex or the 14040 Northern Pike Konrad Flex offer excellent performance and decent permanence. And if you're looking for a lubricated, easy-to-clean permanent blue, the 19204 Eel Gruene Cactus is a fantastic choice. Whichever you choose, Noodler's offers a wide range of permanent blues to suit every need and preference.

• Consider your primary use: art, everyday writing, or calligraphy.
• Think about pen maintenance and cleaning effort.
• Test different inks to see which behaves best with your pens.

In the end, Baystate Blue stands out for its extreme permanence and vibrant color, but it's not the only permanent blue worth considering. Alternatives like the 19094 Akhmatova, 19052 Dark Matter, and 19204 Eel Gruene Cactus offer different balances of performance and convenience. We encourage you to explore these options and find the perfect permanent blue for your writing style. For a deep dive into the world of Noodler's inks, check out our other comparison guides.